Emma
Pacheco
Professor
Flack
English
6
26
November 2012
Rough
Draft#1
Power that Women Hold in The Duchess of Malfi
Intro:
During the Seventeenth century women were seen as inferior to men and usually
had extreme restrictions on what they could or could not. Yet, because of works
such as Geoffrey Chaucer’s “The Wife of Bath” allowed an opportunity to
criticize the realities that women had to face and allowed more control in
their lives. Although the shift was small, there were more authors that began
to show the realities of gender relationships and women’s very complex roles
that started to develop some type of empowerment; however, females had to work
harder to maintain control over their lives. As demonstrated in John Webster’s,
The Duchess of Malfi, the protagonist
struggles against her violent and possessive brothers and tries to display
control over her own life in a more passive manner. Although people can display
power in different ways, there was a difference in the way that men and women
were able to attain power based on the expectations of their gender. For instance, women in a patriarch society
were expected to be submissive and were not allowed to speak their minds.
However, the women in The Duchess of
Malfi, illustrate different ways power is explored whether it was through
their own will or through lustful passive or active, which opened up a new way
on how women are viewed not only in drama but also in society.
Paragraph 1: Duchess and her display of power and how she maintains
it through her strong will and rebelling against her brothers. Deviating
against the norm by deciding her own marriage and concealing it.
The story deals with the Duchess being
subjugated by her brothers who seemed to restrict her to marry after becoming a
widow. However there are themes of
social and sexual mobility as discussed in Fred Wigham’s article “Sexual and
Social Mobility in The Duchess of Malfi” that “Upon [the Duchess’] husband's
death she entered a new realm of freedom from male domination, the only such
realm open to Jacobean women, and it is this transformation that directly
enables her outlaw marriage” (171). Since she became widowed so young, she
expressed her marital freedom to marry again, but the second time was out of
love. She gains more confidence and can explore different reasons to love and
choose to marry out of her class. Even though she claims that she will never
marry, her brother the Cardinal exclaims “So most widows say; / But commonly
that motion lasts no longer / Then the turning of the hourglass”(1.3.12-14).
Basically, acknowledging that women staying widows and maintaining what was
seen as a respectable image was a disappearing norm. keeping their reputation
has completely changed and they realize. This addresses
-Paragraph 2: Julia’s character and the difference in display of
power through sexual means but it still deviates from the norm during this time
period.
However, that is not the only way that
power is demonstrated in the Duchess of Malfi such as the mistress of the
Cardinal, Julia. Through her licentious nature she tries to rise up by being
married to As explained in Fred Wigham’s article ““Self-giving will of another
sort, practiced by Julia, deflects the judgmental charge of lasciviousness away
from the duchess” (172). Illustrating a
different type of power to have control on the men they have. Julia seems to be
the opposites because she uses her sex as a way of gaining only remains loyal
to one man after he agrees to marry her.
Paragraph 3: Cariola also deviates from the norm and goes against
the role of a caretaker by following the role of being obedient servant but
instead does it at “self-giving” doing out of her own will
In addition to Julia displaying
power, one must not forget the Duchess’s caretaker Cariola who also deviates
away from the norm of obeying every word she attests to female self-direction the
Duchess’ secret marriage and assisting the Duchess in her own decisions for a
life of self-control.
Paragraph 4: Having a mind of their own but using their social class
power to do what they want.
Paragraph 5: Men’s easier ability to raise in social class such as Antonio rise. Cardinal’s and Ferdinand’s tyranny.
Paragraph 5: Men’s easier ability to raise in social class such as Antonio rise. Cardinal’s and Ferdinand’s tyranny.
Conclusion:
Overall all these women display
different forms of control either over their lives and decisions but it is a
great deviation from the norm during the Jacobean era. Even each of them tried
to maintain their own power, but this greatly revolutionized a new way of
thinking in terms of…